Friday, October 9, 2009

Obama for Nobel Peace Price

So, it was announced today that this year's Nobel Peace price goes to Barack Obama, president of the United States. Let me be the first to say "Huh?!"

I'm perhaps naive here, but I assumed the Peace price was like the other Nobel prices in that it went to people who had, you know, actually done something. I mean, he's been president for all of nine months, and all he's done is basically to continue a withdrawal of occupying forces in Iraq that his predecessor already initiated. The Norwegian Nobel committee's handwaving about giving hope for the future sounds suspiciously like giving, say, the price in chemistry to some young researchers with the motivation that they're young and bright and seem likely to discover something significant in the future. Sure, Obama improved the prospects for peace simply by replacing Bush, but frankly, a moderately bright gerbil winning the presidency would have had the same result.

The Peace price has often been criticized for being controversial. This is not controversial however; this is just vaguely embarrassing.


Anonymous said...

I love Obama, but I totally agree with you Janne.

If it had been awarded to him a few years in the future after he had done something truly peaceworthy it would've been a great statement. But at this point it's fodder for conservative pundits to label him as only a symbol and celebrity with few real accomplishments.

To give Obama credit, his speech upon learning he had received the award was self-deprecating.

Terrance in Kobe

Janne Morén said...

He's bright, he's articulate and he at least seems to have a fairly open mind. So yes, I vastly prefer him over the alternatives. That said, from my standpoint (Scandinavian center-left; it's probably indistinguishable from communism for many Americans) he is still a religious conservative; would he stand for election in Sweden I would certainly not vote for him.

"To give Obama credit, his speech upon learning he had received the award was self-deprecating."

Well, he couldn't very well thank them for recognizing his many accomplishments, now could he? ^_^

Jallen said...

I agree with you....maybe he should have won the Toastmater award as a Great Speaker.